Q and A – Brexit’s Curse


Dear Ben

I’m very confused as to what’s going on with Brexit, the UK Government and its Constitution at the moment.

Ben: Don’t worry. You’re  meant to be. For several reasons.

It’s just the out-playing of the Brexit Curse

1) PM Johnson’s  position is utter nonsense. We don’t know whether negotiations with the EU are on-going or not. The EU doesn’t know what the UK wants. It has just produced a series of “non-papers”  with “non-ideas” in them and told EU negotiators not to show them to the EU Heads of State.

Comment: For the series “here’s what we might want, but don’t tell anybody because we know it’s stupid. That’s why we won’t admit we want it”

Last Thursday the Brexit Secretary Steve Barclay appeared to threaten Ireland with medicine shortages and Spain with devastation to its fruit and vegetable exports, as well as its tourism and fisheries industries.

Comment:  The UK doesn’t seem to realise  that for the first time in centuries it can no longer boss the EU countries about, play one off against the other or threaten them  to get its own way

2)Brexit has shattered  the entire concensus UK governance was based on.

Risultati immagini per splintered mirror

It has split people and political parties down the middle. The Tories are floundering and flailing. The LIB-Dems want to revoke Art 50 notification of Brexit.

Labour wants to negotiate a New Deal which it may, or may not support, in a people’s Vote  Referendum.

The SNP wants no Brexit even though it could be a trigger for IndyRef2.

The DUP wants NI to be exactly the same as Great Britain – even though it’s not in so many areas – power-sharing. petition of concern, LGBT and women’s rights. language rights etc,.In trying to out-English the English, the DUP support the ERG, a No Deal Brexit and to Hell or Connaught with the Belfast/Good Friday Agreement.

Comment: It’s just starting to dawn on the DUP  that Brexit-related unemployment, impoverishment and havoc, which the majority of people living in NI don’t want under any circumstances,  do not constitute a   vote winning strategy

3)Brexit has widened the gaps between England, Scotland N.Ireland and, to an ever-growing extent, Wales. People are starting to realise what the  negative fall-out  of Brexit will be, in whatever shape or form it takes. Non-English and non-Unionists resent being taken out of the EU at England’s decision  and being told their votes and opinions don’t count.

Comment: Support is rising for Scottish Independence, Irish Re-Unification and even Welsh Independence as they attempt to remain within the EU. The UK Government and Unionist parties have decided there will be no IndyRef2 for Scotland or Border Poll for Ireland. There’ll be no way out of Brexit Britain for them – not under any circumstances

4) Brexit has smashed the  so-called British Constitution and its Conventions to smithereens.

Risultati immagini per splintered looking glass

That was the looking-glass the UK used to tell itself and anyone who would listen how wonderfully democratic and civil it was and how its way was the only way to do things and order society.

Comment: The wonder is that so many people accepted this self-assessment and believed in the image for so long  – without ever  questioning it. 

Why was Parliament prorogued?

Ben: The Government says to prepare a Queen’s speech.

Others say to silence parliament.

The Supreme Court Judges will tell us why next week.

Agreement with the Government signifies parliament can be suspended whenever, and for as long as. any future Government may want.

Agreement with the plaintiffs means Parliament will  be re-opened and that the PM “misled” Her Majesty

Did he?

Ben: Doubt it. She knew what she was doing. If she didn’t  . .. there’s a strong argument that abdication is needed

Did the Queen know what she was doing when she  intervened in the Scottish Referendum?

Ben: What happened?

As the  Queen was leaving Crathie Kirk near her Balmoral estate  after the Sunday morning service, she  told a well-wisher: “Well, I hope people will think very carefully about the future.

What did that mean?

Ben: It was a warning along the lines of “Be careful about what you’re going to do”. Nobody says that if the other person is going to do what the speaker approves of

 Comment: She interfered because she could and she wanted to.

  She had to agree to set up that scene and be filmed as she spoke the (in)famous words.

Why can nobody say what they’ve spoken to the Queen about?

Ben: Because she doesn’t want them to. If nobody knows what she says or thinks she can   project the image of an impartial Sovereign who is above the fray of politics

But is she really?

Ben: She has been meeting the Prime Ministers of Her Governments every week for the past 60+ years.They regard the meetings as a privilege  because “I’m the only non-Royal that gets to see her regularly”

I doubt if their conversations have been limited to “Terrible weather we’re having! More tea? How are the children?”

Otherwise busy PM’s would have reduced the number of meetings or bowed out of them totally long ago.They would have regarded them as a tedious task, rather than a privilege

Since they haven’t, I presume she tells the PM what to do about the various issues that arise at each meeting. And s/he agrees to carry out the Sovreign’s will


The Brexit confusion has been created as the UK Government desperately flounders in a situation of its own making, flailing its arms, kicking and stamping its feet to create chaos. Brexit, besides shattering links with the EU,  risks breaking up the UK, tearing the veil of secrecy from Monarchy, and exposing how a non-codified Constitution is manipulated to suit the Monarchy and its Government.

Journalists, pundits and spokespersons are focusing on separate pieces and shards of glass

Risultati immagini per splintered looking glass

No one is making any previsions about what’ll happen in the next few hours, never mind the end of October when the latest EU extension ends.

Finally ….

The mirror crack’d from side to side;
“A curse is come upon me,” cried
The  UK’s Prime Minister.

Are you a Trotskyist? Discover your Inner Trot! Take this short quiz and find out

In view of the   British Labour Party Deputy Leader’s comments about entryism, Trots under the bed, and in the party and who invited them? or are they just gate-crashers?, this quiz was designed to placate your inner doubts about whether you might be a closet Trot.


Your daughter comes home with bad grades at school. What do you do?

A. Pay for extra-curricular lessons in her weakest subjects.

B. Promise to reward her if her grades improve.

C. Photoshop her image out of every family photograph in your collection.

The back garden needs mowing. Do you …

A. Do it yourself.

B. Get one of the kids to do it.

C. Form a family planning committee to put into place a 5 year plan leading to the collectivisation of the labour and a glorious 240% increase in grass cutting output. On pain of death.

You are elected onto the Parent Teachers Association at your children’s primary school. What do you do at the first meeting?

A. Make several suggestions about how to improve the workings of the school.

B. Decide to listen to the others before making a contribution.

C. Stand up and make a five-hour-long speech in which you denounce half the attendees as traitors to class struggle.

 Your boss informs the staff at your office there will be no pay rises this year due to the ongoing economic crisis. How do you react?

A. Reluctantly accept the news. After all everyone has to tighten their belts in times of economic hardship.

B. Take the matter up with your local trade union representative.

C. Urge your fellow workers to form a Workers Self Defence Unit to storm your boss’s home before taking his family hostage and bayoneting them to death.

Like many teenagers, your 14-year-old son is going through a bit of a rebellious phase and refusing to do as he’s told. Do you …

A. Punish him by grounding him and taking his mobile phone off him for a week?

B. Try to resolve the conflict by encouraging him to talk to you about his feelings?

C. Lock him up in a psychiatric ward until he sees the error of his degenerate bourgeois ways?

 What is the best way to reduce the scourge of violent crime in society?

A. Give the police more powers of search and arrest.

B. Increase funding for youth training schemes, take measures to decrease youth unemployment and invest in inner city sports facilities.

C. Ban ice picks.


7. You decide to take a well-earned holiday. What do you do?

A. Book a quiet week in a boarding house at the English seaside.

B. Go on a package holiday somewhere warm like Greece or Italy.

C. Take a trip to Mexico and shack up at the home of a famous Mexican artist, repaying his hospitality by shagging his wife.


You’re really unhappy with growing inequality in the country and hardship for the poorest while the wealthiest people enrich themselves further at taxpayers’ expense. Do you …

A. Sign petitions and write a letter to your MP?

B. Try to be more involved in politics by joining a political party?

C. Write a 58-page treatise on the urgent need to create a vanguard party of the proletariat, destroy bourgeois capitalist imperialism and create a dictatorship of the workers based on working class self-emancipation and mass democracy?



Thanks to Tom Pride at Pride’s Purge


Worried you might be a Trotskyist Bolshevik without knowing it? Worry no more! Take this quiz and find out: ARE YOU A TROTSKYIST?

Source: Are you a Trotskyist? Take this short quiz and find out: